Introduction: In this article, Gena Philibert-Ortega searches old newspapers to see what our ancestors had for their Thanksgiving feast 100 years ago, in 1926. Gena is a genealogist and author of the book “From the Family Kitchen.”
What did your family eat for Thanksgiving a hundred years ago? While the food found on the Thanksgiving table in 1926 was similar to ours (except for the more modern green bean casserole), there are some differences that reflect what part of the United States they lived in, their personal family food history, budget, where they were eating their meal and with whom.
If you’re like me and didn’t inherit the family cookbook or Thanksgiving-themed recipe cards, the historical newspaper for the area your ancestor lived might hold clues to what recipes they may have used for their holiday meal. Don’t forget to also check out the grocery store sales advertisements to understand the cost of that holiday feast.

Photo credit: https://depositphotos.com/home.html
Thanksgiving Recipes for the Entire Weekend
In some cases, Thanksgiving recipe articles were republished in newspapers across the country and don’t necessarily reflect one area. This Winton-Salem Journal full-page spread is an example of that. It can be found in several newspapers outside of North Carolina.
What I like about this food page is that it includes not only Thanksgiving-day menus but also recipes for the weekend after to assist hostesses who were feeding guests over several days and not just for the big meal.

While some Thanksgiving leftovers are reused in the weekend recipes, including Saturday’s Deviled Turkey and mashed potatoes, new foods are introduced such as pork tenderloin. Some of the menu recipes are found on this page including the Deviled Turkey.
You may wonder, “What is Deviled Turkey?” In this recipe it might have to do with the turkey sauce ingredients which include onion and green peppers. Typically, any food that is “deviled” contains hot or heavily seasoned ingredients (for example deviled eggs contain mustard).

Old-Time Thanksgiving
Even people in 1926 saw some Thanksgiving foods as being “old timey.” Whether they were or not is up for debate and would require further research. Here’s an example of an old-time Thanksgiving holiday menu circa 1926.

Is it an old-time menu? For us in 2026, it definitely is. I was surprised to see Cider Frappe on the menu and thought that was more “futuristic.” But looking at the recipe, it would seem their definition of a frappe is a little different than what ours might be. The recipe appears above the menu in this article and is similar to a sherbert. It calls for apple cider, orange juice and gelatin. Ingredients are combined and then frozen.
The best part of this food newspaper spread by Sister Mary is that it includes a separate article on leftovers. She writes that hostesses probably have turkey leftovers and that larger pieces can be served as is, but smaller pieces might take a little more creativity. She suggests three recipes: Turkey a La King, Turkey Au Graton, and Turkey Timbales.
You might be able to visualize what the first two are, but what is a timbale? Timbale refers either to the preparation or the container used to cook the recipe. In this case, I think it refers to the use of a mold. The recipe calls for the ingredients (turkey, eggs, bread, butter, celery, parsley, milk, salt and pepper) to be combined and then placed in a mold – but not layered, as is the case for some timbale recipes.
Food Columnists and Thanksgiving
It makes sense that food columnists shared their thoughts on the holiday meal preparation in their November articles. The columnist Bertha M. Harris, who wrote “Kitchen Talk,” gave a few suggestions for the holiday meal in 1926: pumpkin pie, cranberry sauce, and “perhaps mashed turnips or stuffed onions.” (Onions obviously played a bigger part in the 1926 meal. This is the 2nd newspaper onion recipe mentioned.)

Harris looks to her readers for recipes to share; one provides her great-grandmother’s pumpkin pie recipe (she includes the reader’s name and address as well but not the great-grandmother’s). One reader provides a Thanksgiving salad recipe, Tomato Jelly Salad, that might not be part of your Thanksgiving feast. The recipe includes gelatin, sugar and tomatoes. She suggests adding it to a mold or teacups.
Other Creative Dishes
Aside from the Tomato Jelly Salad, maybe your family prided themselves on other creative food choices. This next article says it all: Sweet Potato Volcano for a Thanksgiving surprise. A food volcano would indeed be a surprise.

Let’s Just Go Out
Not everyone cooks for Thanksgiving. Whether you don’t like cooking, have no one to cook for, or don’t like Thanksgiving food, going out is always an option. Restaurants are not just a modern choice; they were also an option 100 years ago. Search historical newspapers to see what menu items restaurants in your ancestor’s hometown were serving. This “Where to Dine” newspaper page gives several options including the menu and price in Trenton, New Jersey.

Happy Thanksgiving!
Whether you cook a modern feast or one that includes older family recipes – or you choose to dine out – have a happy Thanksgiving!
Create a free account at GenealogyBank for 7 days to start your journey and discover the stories your ancestors left behind.
Note on the header image: Happy Thanksgiving display. Photo credit: https://depositphotos.com/home.html